Redolent of the worst aspects of Section 28, the current frenzy among Britain’s right-wing reactionary tabloids and supposedly respectable conservative newspapers (The Telegraph) and other commentators is reaching fever pitch.
Section 28 of the Local Government Act 1988 was a law passed in 1988 by a Conservative government that stopped councils and schools “promoting the teaching of the acceptability of homosexuality as a pretended family relationship.” It came about in part after a complaint about a book titled Jenny Lives with Eric and Martin by Susanne Bösche. Headlines from the Daily Mail in the wake of this included Save the children from sad, sordid sex lessons (4th June 1986) and Bizarre truth about happy family in the gay schoolbook (22nd September 1986). Then Education Secretary, Kenneth Baker, declared that this grossly offensive homosexual propaganda’ was put into libraries by ‘left-wing authorities’.
Ancient history? It was not very long ago or far away, and this all looks and sounds very familiar if you have been paying attention over the past few years
The Sun ran with this article earlier this year: TRANS DAD BOOK RAP Fury as ‘irresponsible’ school reading list for children aged 10 includes book about a trans dad (link to archived article)
Recent articles from The Daily Mail include: Schools ignore parents’ concerns over diversity reading lists as young children exposed to ‘trans-activist’ books without their permission(link to archived article)
and:
Trans lobby hijacking primary school reading with ‘sex-change propaganda’ as damning report reveals more than 60 books featuring children ‘born in the wrong body’, women with beards and bizarre ‘non-binary’ guinea pigs(link to archived article)
The Telegraph has published several articles over the past few years including:
‘Sparkly’ pro-trans books targeting toddlers (link to archived article)
Trans books for toddlers are an outrage (link to archived article)
‘Woke’ libraries stock more trans than gender-critical books, data shows (link to archived article)
The report referenced in some of the articles was released by three anti-trans organizations. SEEN in Publishing, Transgender Trend and Biology in Medicine, the report describes the alleged capture of children’s publishing and library services by trans activism. It is titled:
Through the Looking Glass: trans activism in children’s literature and library services
You can find a copy of the report (not hosted by Transgender Trend) by clicking on the link above or here.
While this report deserves a well thought out and comprehensive rebuttal, I am not going to attempt to do so here, as I wanted to use it as an example of one of the tools being made available to potential book banners and censors. Just looking at the recommendations made in the report (pages 10-12) makes it clear what their end goal is. The recommendations boil down to:
- Stop publishing trans-activist literature – fiction as well as non-fiction – for all age groups catered to by children’s publishing, up to and including YA.
- Children’s librarians must stop shelving trans-activist titles.
- Librarians and booksellers must stop recommending trans-activist titles to parents and children
- Instead of publishing trans-activist titles, children’s publishing should concentrate on putting out excellent stories with captivating characters
- The CEOs of publishing houses, their imprint heads and publishing directors should be mandating that acquisitions lists are broadened out again to attract genuinely diverse and excellent submissions
- Children’s publishing and the library services must move away from cancel culture by implementing robust HR practices
- Educational publishing, libraries and schools must collaboratively observe statutory KCSIE and RSHE guidance, ensuring age-inappropriate and factually-incorrect, trans-activist books no longer find their way into children’s hands
That the authors of this report are so open about their aims of banning and censoring books to push transgender folks out of the public eye is concerning to say the least. The language used in the report contains gems like ‘trans-activist literature’ in place of children’s books, teen books and picture books; conflating a drop in reading for pleasure with a rise in the publication of books by and about transgender people, raging about the ‘trans cult’ and the claim that CILIP (the Chartered Institute of Library & Information Professionals) & library services have a ‘preference for trans-activist children’s books’ would be laughable if they were not so deadly serious.
The report and the news articles linked to above feel like early positioning for supporting concepts like ‘Parents rights’ – the idea that adults can control and limit what books and information children can access in schools and libraries.
Back in 2022 Simon James Green became one of the first YA authors to have a school visit cancelled due to his books containing LGBTQ+ themes. He wrote about his experience here: We’re not banned, but…
Authors Kristina Rahim and Jen Carney both discuss having school visits cancelled due to some LGBTQ+ content in their works in this article from The Bookseller: LGBTQ+ authors see school visits cancelled after ‘complaints from parents’ (link to archived article)
Author Ian Eagleton has also posted about children being removed from his school visits due to LGBTQ+ content is his books: https://www.instagram.com/p/DaLmVlgjs-T/?img_index=1
Schools in the UK are on their summer break so it no new information may break for some time, but if any authors, library folk or teaching staff would like to contact me in confidence you can do so using the methods outlined on the Submit News section of my website.
