Category Archives: Libraries

What will be lost if the IMLS is dismantled?

The Institute of Museum and Library Services funds hundreds of initiatives in museums and libraries across the USA. Most of these are invisible because they just work and they support projects that most people don’t notice because they have always been there or are services that are so closely intertwined with the mission of libraries that it seems impossible to imagine that they may not always be available.

These are just some of the essential services that are covered in many libraries by the IMLS.

Are you aware that Inter-Library Loans (ILL) are made possible through IMLS funding? Find out more here: https://action.everylibrary.org/imlsill

Broadband access: Libraries play a significant role in providing digital access and encouraging adoption of internet use, which impacts the health and vitality of communities. The IMLS FY 2015 Public Library Survey showed that 99.2% of public libraries provide internet access. IMLS’s largest grant program, Grants to States, helps libraries assess connectivity needs, procure affordable broadband services, complete E-rate applications, train staff, and obtain technology.

Veteran Services: Community Salute is an IMLS initiative aimed at strengthening the ability of libraries, archives, and museums (LAMs) to respond to the needs of the nation’s 22 million veterans and military families.

Maker Spaces: IMLS funds important work to advance research, promote professional development, and support promising practices for makerspaces and maker programming nationwide. 

Early Learning: IMLS supports the goals of the Campaign for Grade-Level Reading. In recent years, the agency has invested over $2 million in grants to libraries and museums to improve school readiness, reduce summer reading loss, and lower chronic school absence.

Workforce Development: IMLS supports grants to states that promote workforce development through libraries. In the latest Five-Year Plans (2023-2027) from the State Library Administrative Agencies, over half of states and territories (53%) indicated activities related to workforce development, and almost half (44%) indicated plans to coordinate with workforce agencies. Grant-funded library projects demonstrate a range of approaches.

Digital Initiatives: Expanding digital access: IMLS supports projects that increase digital inclusion, broadband access, and digital literacy, giving communities access to information on a wide spectrum of topics, such as education, workforce development, public safety, and health.

Digitizing collections: New technologies help museums improve how they collect, preserve, and enable the use of cultural collections. IMLS supports projects that expand the capacity of museums to serve as memory institutions.

Facilitating open research: Researchers and scholars rely on digital technologies like open source software, as well as open science, open scholarship, and open data. IMLS supports grants that build the technology used for research and scholarly communications.

Emergency Preparedness and Disaster Response: IMLS has invested in building the capacity of museums and libraries to prepare for and respond to disasters. As holders of cultural and natural heritage, these institutions can experience catastrophic losses as the result of natural and other disasters; however, they can also be integral to community efforts to recover and build resilience.

Accessibility: IMLS funding helps increase accessibility and maximize inclusion at museums and libraries throughout the nation. Grant projects have focused on improving the accessibility of nature center wildlife trails, training school librarians to better serve students with disabilities, and developing services for children with autism spectrum disorders.

STEM: IMLS supports STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) education through discretionary grant programs, the Grants to States program, and special initiatives.

Civic Engagement: IMLS has a proud legacy of supporting the critical work that museums and libraries do to engage the citizens in their communities and expand access to and information on voting.

Discover what the IMLS has funded on a state by state level: IMLS Interactive Map

The Institute of Museum and Library Services

UPDATE:

On Monday March 31st, journalist Marisa Kabas broke the news that staff at IMLS were being placed on administrative leave for up to 90 days:

This is the email just received by IMLS staffers placing them on paid administrative leave for up to 90 days. “Please understand that this action is not punitive but rather is taken to facilitate the work and operations of the agency.”

— Marisa Kabas (@marisakabas.bsky.social) 2025-03-31T18:56:42.273Z

This will effectively halt all work being done by employees at the Institute. There are also, as yet uncorroborated reports that a swathe of grants and contracts are in the process of being cancelled.

The DOGE Axe Comes for Libraries and Museums – Wired

The Institute of Museum and Library Services has long received bipartisan support. But after years of trying, President Donald Trump has delivered it a crushing blow.

EveryLibrary Statement on IMLS Staff Administrative Leave:

EveryLibrary expresses deep appreciation and unwavering support for the Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS) staff, who were placed on administrative leave as of today following the Trump Administration’s Executive Order…

The Institute for Museum and Library Services Was Just Gutted – Kelly Jensen Book Riot

Entire staff at federal agency that funds libraries and museums put on leave – NPR

Created by an Act of Congress (the Museum and Library Services Act of 1996) The Institute of Museum Services, which was established in 1976 was merged with the Library Programs Office of the Department of Education. By doing this, Congress achieved the aim of creating an agency that could strategically support libraries and museums in the USA.

The IMLS is the main source of Federal support for Libraries and Museums in the USA. The mission of IMLS is to advance, support, and empower America’s museums, libraries, and related organizations through grantmaking, research, and policy development. [source: https://www.imls.gov/about/learn-about-imls/our-mission-vision]

On March 14, President Donald Trump targeted the IMLS and several other agencies in the Executive Order titled Continuing the Reduction of the Federal Bureaucracy. Now as the IMLS was created by an Act of Congress, a mere EO is not enough (legally speaking) to destroy a Federal Agency, but as the actions of the current administration via the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) have run roughshod over the parts of the federal government that President Trump and other members of the cabal running the US government disagree with have shown, until courts and Congress stand up against this lawlessness, they seem set on ignoring the checks and balances that have formed part of the US government since it was founded.

So libraries that are reliant on IMLS grants to keep their doors open may have service standards imposed upon them to keep their funding or face massive staff cuts and even closure. Of course it will be painted as IMLS grants paying for Drag Queen Storytimes and DEI events. Focusing on the worst human impulses to support what is being done – You don’t want YOUR tax dollars to pay for that do you? The fraud/waste/abuse playbook is already in play across the government.

The Deputy Secretary of Labor, Keith Sonderling was named Acting Director of the IMLS and is expected to enter the IMLS today, backed by a team from DOGE. [source: Marisa Kabas https://bsky.app/profile/marisakabas.bsky.social/post/3lkr67qbqe22i]

LINKS

ALA FAQ: Executive Order Targeting IMLS

Stop What You Are Doing and Talk to Your Patrons About the Proposed IMLS Cuts Today! by Becky Spratford – concrete actions people can take to protest the attack on the IMLS

Seeds of Innovation: Defending IMLS

Actions you can take to protest the proposed axing of the IMLS:

Take Action To Save Federal Funding for Libraries!

Show Up for Libraries

Find your members of Congress here: https://www.congress.gov/members/find-your-member

Call them with this app: https://5calls.org/

Or fax them: https://faxzero.com/fax_congress.php

Urgent: Act Now to Save IMLS

LIVE UPDATES OF DOGE IN IMLS:

Reddit user Ruskiytroll is posting on the fednews subreddit about the DOGE takeover of the IMLS: https://www.reddit.com/user/ruskiytroll

r/fednews is an unofficial secure platform for US Federal employees to discuss work-related topics, share perspectives, and stay informed.

News:

Keith E. Sonderling Sworn In as Acting Director of Institute of Museum and Library Services

WASHINGTON – Deputy Secretary of Labor Keith E. Sonderling was sworn in as Acting Director of the Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS) today, after being designated to the role by President Donald J. Trump. IMLS, an independent government agency, is the primary source of federal support for the nation’s museums and libraries.

“It is an honor to be appointed by President Trump to lead this important organization in its mission to advance, support, and empower America’s museums and libraries, which stand as cornerstones of learning and culture in our society. I am committed to steering this organization in lockstep with this Administration to enhance efficiency and foster innovation. We will revitalize IMLS and restore focus on patriotism, ensuring we preserve our country’s core values, promote American exceptionalism and cultivate love of country in future generations,” said Acting Director Sonderling.

Source: White House Announces Keith E. Sonderling as IMLS Acting Director

Federal agency responsible for library and museum funding gets a visit from DOGE -NPR

Latest Trump cuts put summer reading, mobile libraries and local museums in jeopardy – USA Today

Board Advising IMLS Tells Acting Director Mandates ‘Cannot’ Be Hindered – Publishers Weekly

The National Museum and Library Services Board has laid out the Institute of Museum and Library Services’ statutory obligations in a letter to its acting director, Keith Sonderling, as supporters continue to speak out on behalf of the embattled federal agency

Library Advocates Rally as Trump Targets Federal Funding – New York Times

Library supporters are rallying to the defense of the Institute of Museum and Library Services, warning that the Trump administration’s efforts to pare back or even eliminate the agency will damage institutions across the country and potentially violate the law

The Guantánamo Bay Library Association

A few days ago in a fit of gallows humour after reading too much of the Project 2025 policy document I made a social media post referencing the Guantánamo Bay Library Association as one of the many threats contained within P2025 is the criminalization of library workers.

My joke (& fear) is that we will be rounded up in one of the purges following the expulsion of undocumented immigrants and, at best, locked up in Gitmo. The thought that there will eventually be a Guantánamo Bay Library Association (because library folk love organizing) came from that musing as did a belief that we can do something to sway people to avoid this path that looms before us. SO I have created this post where people can find resources to help push back against this possibility and (possibly) gain inspiration to educate our library patrons about this very real threat.

These are some resources that may be useful:

EveryLibrary helps public, school, and college libraries win funding at the ballot box, ensuring stable funding and access to libraries for generations to come. We also support grassroots groups across the country defend and support their local library against book banning, illicit political interference, and threats of closure. https://www.everylibrary.org

Banning Books and the Law: https://www.findlaw.com/education/student-rights/banning-books-and-the-law.html

Kelly Jensen of BookRiot has been sounding the alarm about the threat to libraries for years: https://bookriot.com/category/literary-activism

Penguin Random House How We’re Fighting Censorship: Legal Action: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/articles/what-were-doing-legal-action

Lawsuits Against Book Bans Begin to Gain Traction https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/books/story/2024-01-11/from-iowa-to-florida-lawsuits-against-book-bans-begin-to-gain-traction

https://pen.org/issue/free-the-books

A tip sheep for library workers facing harassment https://pen.org/librarian-tip-sheet-harassment

Illinois’ new anti-book ban legislation is an initiative of Secretary of State and State Librarian Alexi Giannoulias, who was sworn into office as the state’s 38th Secretary of State in January 2023. https://www.banbookbans.com

17 States Are Considering Laws That Would Imprison Librarians https://www.vanityfair.com/news/17-states-are-considering-laws-that-would-imprison-librarians

The School Board Project https://www.schoolboardproject.com

A while ago I put together a basic intro to Project 2025 booklist providing a visual representation of some of the changes that will be enacted if the aims of Project 2025 are put into practice, as well as links to the relevant chapter of The Mandate for Leadership that details how this will happen: https://jocolibrary.bibliocommons.com/list/share/1412410137_jclmatti/2561987729_project_2025

Columnist Molly Jong-Fast and historian Thomas Zimmer about Project 2025—a controversial roadmap unveiled by the conservative Heritage Foundation outlining a radical vision for a second Trump administration. They discussthe projects plans to reshape the U.S. government, ranging from increased presidential control to dismantling protections for minorities and marginalized groups. Zimmer provides insights into the four pillars of Project 2025, the implications for American democracy, and the potential broader impacts on society:

Project 2025 Threatens Library Workers

This screenshot is taken from page five of the forward to the Heritage Foundations Mandate for Leadership.

The text reads:

Pornography should be outlawed. The people who produce and distribute it should be imprisoned. Educators and public librarians who purvey it should be classed as registered sex offenders. And telecommunications and technology firms that facilitate its spread should be shuttered.

The definition of pornography is deliberately vague and appears to label anything not heteronormative as porn. Basically anything that appears to vaguely condone LGBTQ+ lives or exploring gender and sexuality.

The attacks on libraries with the addition of Project 2025 take on a more sinister, coordinated appearance. Any organization or individual that threatens the “innocence” and “purity” of children gets labeled as groomers.

Of course it is predominantly white children that are deserving of protection, but it is ever thus.

You can read the Mandate for Leadership here:

https://www.project2025.org/policy/

I will share resources examining this as they become available.

The anatomy of an attack on a book & library

One of the things I do to keep track of what is happening in right-wing ecosystems with regard to libraries and books is peek at the Facebook pages of some of the right-wing reactionary folk that live in the same general geographic location as me from time to time.

During one of my check-ins I noticed that the person who runs the fb page had shared a post by a county commissioner for a large and populous county in Kansas. The post was a web cartoon by a local conservative cartoonist attacking the library for having a book called You Know, Sex by Cory Silverberg & Fiona Smith in its collection.

Truth Toons cartoon copyright Tim McCabe

I visited the commissioner’s fb page and noted that prior to posting the cartoon she attempted to do an end run around official library procedure by making a post encouraging followers to contact the county librarian as well as the board of county commissioners to complain about the book.

This particular library is incredibly well-resourced and has a comprehensive, publicly available collection development policy as well as a request for reconsideration procedure that is also available for any patrons that wish to have materials moved or withdrawn.

Like some other attempts to fan the flames of indignation online, these posts are light on factual information, using trigger words to cause a negative response in whoever reads them.

Does this book contain information about porn, rape, anal and all of it? Yes it does but it is not gratuitous, it is a guide to being safe and aware. Pornography this book is most definitely not!

Break for a quick book review:

Being an inquisitive sort, I put a request in for a copy of You Know, Sex and what I found may astound you. Yes it is a graphic (as in graphic novel) non-fiction guide to sex, sexuality and gender. It is thoughtfully written and illustrated, with nothing that can be considered prurient, titillating or pornographic. The illustrations of human bodies are presented in all their unique, imperfect glory.

In short this book is about as far from porn as you can get, it introduces concepts and ideas in a way that does not talk down to the reader – whatever their age may be. It is frank, open and honest and contains a LOT of information that can be digested at whatever speed the reader is happiest with. The author addresses the reader in the opening Letter to the Reader acknowledging that sex is a complex subject to learn about, and suggests ways in which to cope with using this book.

It also contains a glossary which is important for fostering better understanding of the subject and an index and resources and organizations that can further understanding of the subject. Another thing I found particularly useful are the tips on searching for information online and URLs for trusted web resources.

If you are a parent, or educator looking for a book about sex for readers of all ages then I highly recommend You Know, Sex for your family or/and library collection.

I will say that you as an adult should also read it – you will definitely learn something and will also be able to discuss it with the young people in your life, if they trust you enough (or, are not too embarrassed) to broach the subject.

—

This is not the first time that the commissioner in question has used her position to attack the library over books for young readers. In 2023 she weighed in on the YALSA Teens Top 10 program that the library was involved with that had upset a parent, from The Heartlander News: Library in suburban Kansas City offers free books to youths, perhaps unnoticed by parents, that portray whites as racists, colonizers

From Free State News comes a slightly reworded piece, similar to the one in The Heartlander News: Johnson County Library distributes pornographic gore to developing teen minds in their Summer Reading Program

Although the change from the Heartlander piece saying “Williams doesn’t accuse the Gardner library, or even the Johnson County library system, of propagating leftist propaganda, but adds, “I do believe 100% that it’s pushed intentionally from a larger agenda, maybe even outside of our state.”

to: “I would like to know what staff created this list, and I would like those people arrested for distributing murder-fetish porn to my child. This should be a criminal offense, punishable by jail time.

In Luke 17:1-2 the Bible states, “Jesus said to his disciples: “Things that cause people to stumble are bound to come, but woe to anyone through whom they come. It would be better for them to be thrown into the sea with a millstone tied around their neck than to cause one of these little ones to stumble.”

I’ll take millstones for 1,000, Alex. These people need to be punished to the full extent of the law for warping and destroying the minds of our youth with their selfish, morbid agendas.” in the Free State news piece is quite a change in tone.

and Could Public and School Libraries be Guilty of Felony Distribution of Obscene Materials to Children per KSA 21-6401?

We are in an election year and it remains to be seen if culture war topics, particularly an attack on a large and popular library over books will be a vote-getter in a county that has been consistently trending purple over the past few years.

National library organisation sounds alarm over ‘fire sale’ of library buildings

The Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals (CILIP), a national charity which exists to raise standards in library provision has sounded the alarm over a potential ‘fire sale’ of library buildings following the Government announcement of ‘exceptional financial support’ to 19 Councils[1].

The Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities has announced that 19 councils in England will benefit from an ‘Exceptional Financial Support (EFS)’ framework for the fiscal year 2024-25, totalling around £1.5 billion.

Rather than representing new investment or capital support, the framework allows the Councils involved to use capital receipts from the sale of assets or borrowing to cover their day-to-day costs up to this amount. Additionally, there is further support for capitalisation requests from previous years amounting to £976 million.

Commenting on the announcement, CILIP interim CEO Jo Cornish said,

This ‘exceptional financial support’ announced by Government is in reality nothing of the sort. Instead, central Government is suggesting that cash-strapped Councils should do the equivalent of using their savings (long-term investment budgets) and selling property to cover day-to-day running costs.

This framework creates a material risk that Councils will sell off parts of their property portfolio, including libraries, to address the funding shortfall caused by the withdrawal of central Government grants. We know from our experience supporting library services across the UK, this is a one-way trip – once a library building is sold off, it permanently impairs the life chances and property values of local residents. It’s a one-way deal and very much like using the credit card to pay the mortgage.

We urgently call on central Government to work with Councils to provide long-term sustainable investment to protect local services and halt their decline, including statutory public library provision.

In response to increasing concerns over proposals to reduce or close library services, CILIP has launched the ‘Libraries at Risk Monitor’ – a regularly-updated map of proposed changes to libraries across the UK with an indication of where CILIP and their partner organisation, CILIP in Scotland are intervening to seek better outcomes for local taxpayers (www.cilip.org.uk/libraries-at-risk).


[1] https://www.gov.uk/guidance/exceptional-financial-support-for-local-authorities-for-2024-25

Another Sign of Libraries under Threat: Chuck Tingle & the Texas Library Association

It is a widely-shared belief that Public Libraries are one of the greatest things that society has come up with. For well over a century they have grown and evolved as places that are safe for all segments of society to use and see themselves reflected in the collections and made to feel welcome.

I am a believer in the potential of Public Libraries and a lifer in the service (30 years as student volunteer and library professional this year). However I do not believe that they are an eternally safe and secure space. Over the decades I have seen libraries under threat from those who should be supporting and defending them. I have seen branches crumble and fall, shedding staff like trees dropping leaves in the fall.

A more insidious threat often comes from above and within, the latest sign of this danger popped up in my social media feed last night, with Chuck Tingle announcing that his invitation to speak at the Texas Library Association had been rescinded.

Chuck wrote a post about it on his Patreon that you can read here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/texas-library-to-96183885

As I have been writing this. the TLA have released a (to my mind very unimpressive) statement:

As much as many Public Library workers attempt to live up to the publicly stated ethos and values of the profession, Libraries have always been controlled by local government, through the boards that oversee the rules and regulations that govern how libraries are managed and run, and, if right wing individuals gain control of these boards they can negatively affect the services that libraries offer.

You can read previous articles I have written about this subject here:

It can’t be up to Library Workers alone to make sure that Libraries live up to their potential of being safe and open to all.

On December 7th a Librarian died in Gaza. 

Doaa al-Masri and her family were killed in an Israeli airstrike on December 7th 2023. 

Doaa receives a group of schoolgirls at the Edward Said Library in Gaza

Why have I focused on Doaa you may ask. Well, we shared a profession and belief in public service, and it is hard to get one’s head around the scale of the tragedy and loss of life that has been unfolding in the Middle East; from the 1,139 Israeli lives lost in the Hamas attacks on October 7th to the sheer brutality of their response across Gaza.

To paraphrase a statement allegedly made by Stalin: 20,000 deaths is a statistic, one death is a tragedy. 

It is not easier to acknowledge a single death that 20,000 but it is less numbing. Each of the thousands of lives lost to this violence will have a ripple effect on thousands more, but their faces blur and get lost in the scale of this tragedy and they become numbers, rather than individuals.

In their tribute to her memory, the Middle East Children’s Alliance (MECA) captured in part her spirit and dedication to her community: 

…Doaa Al-Masri was killed with her family on Thursday night. Doaa was the librarian at the Edward Said Public Library in Gaza. She was a kind and energetic young woman who organized many activities for children and youth at the library including reading groups, classes, and field trips for schools. 

Doaa was also a volunteer in many other projects. During each Israeli attack on Gaza, she joined her colleagues at MECA partner Youth Vision Society in procuring, packing, and delivering emergency aid to children and families. Just last week, in the midst of intense Israeli attacks, she joined two other  volunteers to provide warm clothes to children in northern Gaza. 

We mourn the loss of Doaa, a loss for MECA, for the many children whose lives she touched, and for Palestine. We will miss her smile and her radiant energy. Doaa is one of tens of thousands of people killed in Gaza over the last 64 days. Each one is a terrible loss to those who knew and loved them. 

Let’s be honest, when one thinks of Gaza and the West Bank, Libraries are not the first thing that pop into your mind. No matter who they are or where they live people enjoy reading and need to find information – and those are two of the core functions of public libraries. 

The Gaza Municipal Library and the Rashad al-Shawa Cultural Center that was the home of the Diana Tamari Sabbagh Library  that contained more than 100.000 books and was founded by Haseeb Sabbagh in the memory of his wife Diana Tamari, have both been razed by Israeli forces. There is currently no news on the current condition of the Edward Said Public Library in North Gaza. 

The remains of the Gaza Municipal Library

The Gaza Municipality has alleged that the destruction of libraries by Israeli forces during the conflict has been a deliberate act and has called on the United Nations Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) to intervene and protect cultural centers and condemn the occupation’s targeting of these humanitarian facilities protected under international humanitarian law.

Public Libraries form one of the cornerstones of a society that nurtures and cares for the people that comprise its individual parts. Apart from educating and entertaining their users, libraries function as repositories of history and cultural knowledge. To destroy a society first you wipe out the commonalities that bind them together, their shared history, their art, anything that ties them together and the fastest way to do that is to start with destroying their libraries and those that care for them.

When Libraries in Sarajevo were bombed people stood up and protested, when al Qaeda attacked the library in Timbuktu there was eventually a book celebrating those who stood up to save priceless, ancient manuscripts, when Russia invaded Ukraine there was a massive outpouring of support for Ukrainian Libraries and Library workers. In Gaza there is proof of libraries being destroyed and one confirmed report of a Librarian (& her family) being killed in an aerial attack and nothing – where is the outrage?

Understand me when I write that I unequivocally condemn Hamas for their bloodthirsty action on October 7th, but the heavy-handed response by the Israeli War Cabinet and the IDF is just as reprehensible!

Articles 6, 7 & 8 of The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court specifically outlaw Genocide, Crimes Against Humanity & War Crimes.

Article 33 of the fourth Geneva Convention specifically outlaws collective penalties, pillage & reprisals:

No protected person may be punished for an offence he or she has not personally committed. Collective penalties and likewise all measures of intimidation or of terrorism are prohibited.

Pillage is prohibited.

Reprisals against protected persons* and their property are prohibited.

* The term “protected person” means any person entitled to protection under one or more of the Geneva Conventions, including civilians not taking an active part in hostilities, military personnel placed out of combat by sickness, wounds, or detention, and military medical or religious personnel.

Do the actions of Hamas and the IDF rise to these levels of criminal wrong-doing? I think they do, but untrained as I am in international jurisprudence I may be wrong; I do however know that the murder unarmed civilians is wrong, no matter who does it!

Links:

Founding the First English-Language Library in Gaza by Mosab Abu Toha

Libraries in Gaza: Between Despair and Hope by Mosab Abu Toha

Articles by Mosab Abu Toha

How girls built a library in the Gaza Strip by Mohammed Abu Sulaiman, with Chris Niles

Gaza’s main public library has been destroyed by Israeli bombing. by Dan Sheehan

Gazans mourn loss of their libraries: Cultural beacons and communal spaces by Mohamad El Chamaa

Middle East Children’s Alliance

Youth Vision Association

Youth Vision Association: Edward Said Public Library

Edward Said Public Libraries in Gaza

Librarians and Archivists with Palestine

Book-banners in Mississippi have removed kids access to ebooks

Mississippi Statute 39-3-25 has made it impossible for young readers under the age of 18 to have access to Libby, an eBook platform offered by Overdrive or Hoopla another popular streaming service offered by libraries without permission from parents or guardians.

BookRiot has a comprehensive article about this ban available here.

The Foundations of the US Public Library Service are Cracking

The Missouri Legislature has voted to defund public libraries, I guess the Show Me State does not like people saying “Show me books with gay, trans and minority characters!” to Librarians. Apparently, Texas is trying to go down a similar route and Florida is an even hotter mess these days. A Michigan Library was also defunded and faces potential closure, even after thousands of dollars in donations were raised.

Moms for Liberty has also been incredibly active, as freedom of choice in reading material is not covered under their version of Liberty, they are now targeting a school in the district that my library serves, the librarian there resigned earlier this year and are active across the US.

Library boards are threatening closure when their attempts to remove books are declared unconstitutional rather than put them back on the shelves. Yesterday I saw a tweet from author Maggie Tokuda-Hall about being approached to license her book Love in the Library for their AANHPI narratives collection which would usually be a cause for celebration, except that they wanted to remove a word before the deal could go ahead.

Maggie has written about it on her blog – it is equal parts heart-breaking and infuriating, you can read it here: https://www.prettyokmaggie.com/blog/2023/4/11/scholastic-and-a-faustian-bargain
Scholastic is one of the big dogs in the publishing world, they run book fairs in schools, in the UK they are the official book supplier for the Yoto Carnegie Book Awards, they are everywhere and usually do good work; so, I find it hard to believe that this move is a one-off, how many authors and illustrators have already decided to swallow a bitter pill to accept what appears to be a fantastic deal?

As the clamor to ban books in schools and libraries (and also alarmingly now in bookstores) has started growing louder how many publishers have begun moving behind the scenes to head off criticism instead of supporting their authors and illustrators and the readers who deserve access to books?

Diverse voices in the publishing world (& in libraries) are an incredibly small percentage, of the workforce and also what tis available in print. Hearing about this brazen move by Scholastic I fear that the numbers may become even smaller if publishers are moving to placate the outsize voices of those that are complaining or taking offence at diverse offerings in libraries. Library workers not purchasing works to avoid complaints is a creeping problem in libraries but if publishers are pre-emptively censoring works that they have or wish to make available then the whole edifice made up of publishers, bookstores and libraries becomes unsafe and unwelcoming for everyone.

As a public service Public Libraries are non-partisan and open to all (or they should be), but this new hostile environment being created by a minority of people that use libraries risks skewing the services and materials that libraries offer.