I am currently building a deck of cards based on Librarian Jessamyn West’s www.librarian.net/notoai/ page with extra cards about the risks inherent in AI/LLMs to help people help others disable AI and also have talking points about why genAI is a bad idea.
I have had a load of requests for copies of the cards so I have made the cards I have made so far available to download below. The first file is in US letter size and the second is A4 page size for non US residents.
Perhaps the hardest news I have had to face in my (admittedly tiny) digital creation sphere was the news that our tech overlords at Microsoft decided that their venerable Publisher program will no longer be supported from October 2026. For over a year I ignored the news and indulged in wishful thinking, denial and hope that they would change their minds. Somewhere along the line I decided that this is no way to live my life and for a while now I have been poking alternatives to Publisher so that when October arrives I will be set up on a usable alternative.
It is not easy to say goodbye, many of my library posters were cobbled together in Publisher. You can view my downloadable posters here. Over the years I have flirted with Adobe Express (back when it was still Adobe Spark), I tried Canva briefly and a few other online tools whose names escape me. None of them could take the place of Publisher, at the height of my creative prowess I could slap together a poster, flier or related thing in a matter of minutes, when I had time and inspiration I happily spent hours making eye-catching posters using a variety of tools to tweak the parts that I would put together of a Publisher page, the control I had during my creative process was total. I have colleagues and friends who swear by Canva, when I used it I eventually swore at Canva. It is a perfectly decent tool I am sure, but I do not like ceding control of functions, or having to be online to use it or the many other cloud-based tools that are now available.
If you, like me are fans of Publisher, you may be interested in trying out one, or both of these open source tools that are close to Publisher:
Part of the LibreOffice Suite of Tools developed by The Document Foundation, Draw is a free and open source vector graphics editor that I have found easy to transition to and use. LibreOffice is available to download and install on Linux, Windows and macOS platforms. Honestly if you are trying to get out from under the thumb of tech companies, why not start trying out LibreOffice, it won’t cost you a thing!
Scribus is an open source desktop publishing tool developed by The Scribus Team, who have been shepherding it’s design since 2001. It is available on a variety of platforms including Unix, Linux, BSD, macOS, Haiku, Microsoft Windows and more!
I am still kicking the tyres and getting used to how it works, but I feel that it does have potential as a Publisher replacement although I currently prefer LibreOffice Draw, but that may change as I ttes out Scribus more.
Scribus has an online tutorial for beginners which forms part of a comprehensive wiki for users of all levels that want to up their DTP game.
There are a number of other programs available to replace Publisher (for a price), but in the end it came down to these two because of cost, and cross-platform availability. I have used Linux exclusively on my home computer for a few years now and prefer not to support closed source programs where possible.
I have been doing some deep thinking about the use of AI in Libraries, and like many other colleagues I reached the inescapable conclusion that there is currently no ethical way to use generative AI at all, let alone within Libraries.
As information professionals, Library Workers have historically and contemporaneously firmly positioned ourselves on the side of copyright protection and against piracy and intellectual property theft. It is widely documented that generative AI programs have been trained on illegally downloaded and stolen materials so I am constantly being surprised and horrified when I see colleagues gushing about how much fun they are having learning to use generative AI in their libraries, “It saves so much time”, “I no longer have to think too much about creating lesson plans”. I have been urged not to worry too much about it as AI is the wave of the future and that there is a push to get governments to regulate the companies creating AI programs to make sure that AI training is done legally, but the genie is out of the bottle on that one and barely a day goes by without authors and artists posting more evidence that their works have been stolen by multi-billion dollar organizations to feed the beasts that are their generative AI programs.
Libraries are not immune to the looming threat of generative AI, there have already been reports of AI slop (this is a real term for works created by AI trained on pirated works) appearing on digital platforms such as Hoopla that are available through libraries. I fear that in the not too distant future library services will incorporate AI programs to complement and eventually cut down on paid staff.
Databases containing information about read-alikes, pen names, ghost writers, genres as well as every user-generated tag and category you can think of will be fed into a program that will be able to spit out recommendations when a patron types in a question looking for more books in specific genres or on certain subjects. If such a program is integrated into library management software it will eventually be able to create a patron profile and generate suggestions based on a patron’s reading history and general preferences as well as their use of library digital media and what they access online through library computers. The potential for privacy violations aside, this type of program may end up funneling readers into a reading cul-de-sac, keeping them reading books that they like, which may not seem like a problem but this could prevent them from finding new authors, or reading outside their comfort zones and broadening their reading horizons.
If library services are outsourced and run by for profit entities that own publishing companies, it is entirely possible that an AI program will eventually have enough data scraped from library users to determine the most popular items loaned out by the library; books and stories can then be algorithmically generated, then published by the publishing arm of the company (or just be made available in e-format to keep physical costs down), the local authority that pays the company to run their libraries will be charged for these slop titles that are placed into the collection. They will be catalogued by another AI program and made generally available for library users, eventually it will become a perfect circle of AI generated works based on other slop works that were once based off actual works created by humans.
This horror story may seem like the stuff of paranoid fantasy, but with the current push for AI in all industries it is only a matter time before it is integrated into pubic services and services that once relied on human interaction will be rolled into an customized library AI program.
I was an early fan of Google, from managing to get an early invitation to Gmail, playing with Picasa and following it when it was purchased by Google and eventually became Google Photos, using and enjoying Google Docs and the other offerings in its Office Suite. My first smartphone ran Android (it was the HTC Desire), I ran library lessons on using Google products when I was a School Librarian and I enjoyed the ease of use and interconnectedness Google products offered.
Sadly over the years I have watched Google move from the days of “Don’t Be Evil” and fear that they are approaching their “I’m With Evil” phase, in fact they may already be there.
I have slowly been in the process of Degoogleing my life, and the other day I decided to share (via Bluesky) some replacements for Google products:
Instead of Google search try DuckDuckGo Instead of Chrome try FirefoxInstead of Gmail try ProtonMailInstead of Google Docs etc try LibreOfficeInstead of Google Photos try EnteFor every Google product there are multiple replacements you can try. The above suggestions are just examples to try
That skeet has proven to be extremely popular. So popular in fact, that I decided to create this post with more in-depth suggestions with regard to replacing Google products and services. I will caution at the outset that sometimes there are not like for like products that work in exactly the same way, but for each I will suggest at least one potential replacement you can try out.
Remember when looking to swap out apps and programs from companies that have taken a stance you disagree with, you should take the time to test out and research potential replacements- it is good to take heed of suggestions but find something that fits your particular needs and ethics.
I have limited this list to free to use products. Depending on your needs (& budget) there are a number of subscription services that may meet your needs that you can find with a quick search on your search engine of choice (see below for some examples).
The frustrating thing about this is that Proton offers email, a calendar, cloud storage, a password manager and a VPN all of which are free to use at the basic level. I have included links to these services if your need to deGoogle your life trumps (no pun intended) your dislike of the current US administration.
Broadly speaking, AI is intelligence shown by machines, particularly computer programs. It is a field of research in computer science dedicated to developing and studying software and methods that allow machines to perceive their environment and use their intelligence, bolstered by learning to take actions that will allow them to increase its chances of achieving defined goals.
Are any machines or computer programs actually intelligent?
To put it bluntly no, currently all publicly available “AI” programs are basically a type of machine learning programs known as “large language models” (LLMs) that have been trained on massive amounts of text and images, and with set parameters can generate text and images. True machine intelligence has been hypothesized in science fiction but until the AI singularity occurs true Artificial Intelligence will remain in the realm of science fiction.
What is the AI Singularity?
This is the hypothetical point at which AI systems will achieve the ability to surpass human ingenuity and be able to improve itself and soon after this achieve true intelligence and then (possibly) attempt to destroy humanity.
So how are ‘Large Language Models” trained?
The people programming them load vast quantities of text and images into the program to allow the program to analyze these and learn how to write similar works.
Where did they get these vast quantities of text?
They scraped the entirety of the world wide web and downloaded everything they could find to feed the digital beasts they were creating.
And did they pay for all the works not in the public domain that they downloaded?
Why did they not just use materials that are in the public domain?
To quote a spokesman from OpenAI (creator of the LLM program ChatGPT): “copyright today covers virtually every sort of human expression – including blog posts, photographs, forum posts, scraps of software code, and government documents – it would be impossible to train today’s leading AI models without using copyrighted materials. Limiting training data to public domain books and drawings created more than a century ago might yield an interesting experiment, but would not provide AI systems that meet the needs of today’s citizens.”
So they didn’t want to pay to access all copyrighted material to train their programs because it would have been too expensive?
The creators of LLM AI programs claim that it is fair use to use copyrighted materials to train their programs: we believe that legally copyright law does not forbid training.
So a legal grey area that will have to be fought out in the courts?
mmmmm
OK but is it ethical?
Is it ethical to use a program that has been created using pirated materials in libraries? To quote article 4 of the American Library Association’s Code of Ethics: We respect intellectual property rights and advocate balance between the interests of information users and rights holders. I think as Library Workers we should not be using tools that have been created using methods that may be considered legally, ethically or morally suspect. Most, if not all of us are aware that a majority of authors, musicians and artists struggle to survive on the money they make from what they have created, so to give tacit approval to companies owned by billionaires stealing what they have labored over for years by using Generative AI products so we can push a button to create a generic library lesson plan or library poster that may have one too many fingers or other weird digital glitch is not worth it.
What if I really want to use Generative AI programs at work?
Well I can’t stop you, but I will encourage you to read up on the ethics of using such programs as well as the impact they have on the environment and author incomes. I will put some links to articles below if you would like to start here.
Bluesky is the latest (& arguably greatest) pretender to the vacant throne once held held by Twitter; it appears to be achieving critical mass with close to 17 million accounts signed up as I am writing this. By the time you read this it may well have passed that number! I have been kicking the tyres for the past year and it has rapidly become my favourite of the newer short form social media sites.
Less niche than Mastodon and more usable than Threads, if I were a betting man I would put money on Bluesky becoming the preeminent social site among social sites. Bluesky is rapidly achieving feature parity with Twitter, from sharing short videos, images and links to direct messages, hashtags, lists and more. Possibly the thing that makes it greater that Twitter ever was are the baked in anti-toxicity features, developed to help prevent bullying, piling on and worse.
Rather than rehashing what has gone before, I would recommend anyone interested in using Bluesky to check out author & illustrator Debbi Ridpath Oni‘s Unofficial Guide to Using Bluesky, it is one of the best of (many) the user guides out there, and one that I dipped into a number of times in my early days on Bluesky.
Library Bluesky has been growing at an exponential rate and many of my friends, colleagues and library collaborators have already signed up and I am discovering new (to me) library related folk every day, as well as authors, illustrators, publishers and book bloggers as well. There are a number of feeds, starter packs and lists that created specifically for library folk and those interested in the library world.
The WIRED Guide to Protecting Yourself From Government Surveillance
Donald Trump has vowed to deport millions and jail his enemies. To carry out that agenda, his administration will exploit America’s digital surveillance machine. Here are some steps you can take to evade it:
CILIP started the National Shelf Service on Monday 6th April, a daily recommendation of a book available to borrow electronically through local libraries, live at 11am. Hopefully you’ve been watching these great videos from YLG colleagues, but if you haven’t seen any yet then why not start with mine! I’m the only one (so far) that has talked about a book that isn’t aimed at teenagers or young adults, not really living up to the TeenLibrarian name, but as I say: this book can be read and loved by anyone of any age…
The illustrations on the banners are by Fiona Lumbers, from the book Luna Loves Library Day written by Joseph Coelho
Starting today and running until 3rd February, Wikipedia is hoping to entice Librarians into helping them make their online encyclopaedia more accurate by adding one reference to an article to help it become more reliable then adding #1Lib1Ref in the edit summary to help them track participation.
How to Participate: Five Basic Steps
Find an article that needs a citation. There are many ways to do this. Here are some strategies.
Filling a “Citation Needed” using Citation Hunt
Finding an article with sourcing problems
Select an article while browsing
Cite a source from your collection or research
Find a reliable source that can support that article
Add a citation using Wikipedia Style. Click here to learn about adding citations and editing Wikipedia
Add the project hashtag #1Lib1Ref in the Wikipedia Edit Summary
Share your edit on social media and learn more about libraries and Wikipedia. Grab a userbox for your user page if you’re into that sort of thing.