Category Archives: Books

The Ten Rules of Skimming by Zella Compton & Jess Swainson


Ever had the shivery feeling that someone is walking over your grave?

It’s someone skimming your soul.

Adam finds that skimming brings an amazing rush but joy riding across minds comes with risks.

When he meets Jenny-Ray, he learns about the Board, with their list of approved ‘hosts’ to visit.

The consequences of disobedience are terrifying.

 
The story opens in a dank sub-basement of a hospital where we meet Adam who is being interviewed by a shadowy figure about his illicit activities as a skimmer.

The story is a mix of prose and graphic storytelling which enhances the tale and has the advantage of showing rather than telling what happens during skimming. The story is as much about Adam and his family life and realtionships as it is about the science-fiction aspects of the story but they mesh together well creating a deeper, more enjoyable story. Adam has a relatively unhappy home life and is not the most popular of young people at his school, his faults actually make him more interesting as flawed heroes are often more interesting than squeaky clean characters.

Adam, with his gifts has a range of enemies arrayed against him; and when his sister goes missing, he finds that his only ally is a girl who is studying to join The Board – a group of people that control skimming with an iron fist, but they are not the worst of his problems!

The Ten Rules of Skimming is an exciting, action-packed adventure that mixes science fiction, horror, mystery and intrigue that introduces readers to a world where mind jumping is real if not common- it reads like Inception for YA readers!

I thoroughly enjoyed it!

The Abominators: and My Amazing Panty Wanty Woos!

abominators cover

Mucker, Boogster, Cheesy and Bob, also known as The Abominators, are the most mischievous characters you will ever have come across.

Their interests include chaos, mayhem and filling the school toilets with strawberry jelly.

Their interests definitely DO NOT include making friends with panty-wanty-woo-wearing new boy, Cecil Trumpington-Potts.

Cecil, however, is certain he can change their minds . . .

Before I start with my review I will say that I think that this book would win the award for title of the year if there was such an award – and maybe there should be!

Releasing frogs into the staffroom?

The Abominators did it!

Filling the toilets with strawberry jelly?

The Abominators did it!

Using their body parts during show and tell?

Yes that is the Abominators!

Every school has them, the makers of mayhem, the rabble rousers, the kids who cause chaos for fun and because they can! Grimley East Primary School is perhaps not the best that one can find but it is here that Cecil Trumpington-Potts finds himself after his father Lord T-P loses the family fortune and is forced to enrol his son in the state school system. For young Cecil previously home-schooled it is a dream come true, he will finally get the chance to meet pepole his own age and make friends. Unfortunately he sets his sights on getting into the Abominators, but with his delicate features and love for his panty wanty woos they are not as keen on making his acquaintance…

The Abominators and My Amazing Panty Wanty Woos!
is the first book in The Abominators series, and although aimed at the 7+ market it will be enjoyed by older readers. This book is funny and although I am so far out of the age range as to be positively ancient I still laughed several times! The story boasts five primary characters and a goodly-sized supporting cast the break-out character for me was Cecil’s father Lord Trumpington-Potts, who reminds me a bit of Philip Ardagh crossed with an extremely eccentric character that used to come into one of the libraries I worked in a few years ago.

The main thrust of the novel was hilarious and there are a few side-plots that I am hoping will be developed through the series and as such I am looking forward to further books in the series!
___

Post-script: I read the first chapter to my girlfriend over the phone (we were chatting and she asked me to tell a story) and she asked me if it was a story in the same vein as Wimpy Kid or Horrid Henry which is pretty spot on as it is being marketed as a book for fans of those two series.

Night School: Legacy Blog Tour

Welcome to the Teen Librarian stop on the Night School: Legacy Blog Tour. Legacy is the sequel to the amazing Night School by C.J. Daugherty

For your delectation we have a member card for Night School member Gabe Porthus below as well as the video trailer for Legacy.

If this is the first time you have come across the Night School: Legacy Tour – do not panic! The rules are below the member card as are links to the other stops on the tour!

For complete details about the tour and competition please visit C.J. Daugherty’s Night School’s Members Page

Night School Challenge Rules:

  • Visit 14 book blogs between 3rd – 10th January
  • Locate and collect 14 Night School Skill words
  • Return to the Night School Members page to enter your collected skills by 13th January
  • The entry form will be live from January 10th and will close at midnight on January 13th
  • If you successfully complete the challenge you will become a Night School member for life – when this happens you will receive a membership charter and Night School members badge to download
  • The first ten people to receive Night School membership will be rewarded for their speed with an exclusive Night School goodie bag.
  • Legacy Blog Tour Dates

    Thurs 3rd – Fluttering Butterflies & I Want to Read That

    Fri 4th – Teen Librarian & Mostly Reading YA

    Sat 5th – District YA

    Sun 6th – So Many Books, So Little Time

    Mon 7th – The Bookette & Endlessly Bookish

    Tues 8th – Feeling Fictional & Bookaholics Book Club

    Weds 9th – Pewter Wolf & Book Passion for Life

    Thurs 10th – Serendipity Reviews & Once upon a Bookcase

    The Night Before Christmas: Fuse by Julianna Baggott

    Yes it is that time of year for a Christmas Eve review (in rhyme). This year is a preview of Fuse by Julianna Baggott:


    ‘Twas the night before Christmas
    I was alone in my flat
    Wrapped up in blankets
    And a warm woollen hat.
     
    I had just finished reading
    A book titled “Fuse”
    It blew me away
    Left me emotionally bruised.

    The sequel to “Pure”
    A series quite apocalyptic
    Although the titles don’t hint it
    They are in fact cryptic*

    The Pure are the dome-folk
    Tied up with secrets and lies
    They use special forces
    As assassins and spies
     
     
    Against the Fused, who are people
    with a permanent weld
    To doll’s, babies and cats,
    All things that they held.

    They melted together
    In the great blast
    When society ended
    In a nuke holocaust!

    Now armies are building
    and new plots are hatching
    There are heroes a-growing
    and the villains need catching!

    The series is awesome
    I think you should read it
    If you have a need for apocalypse
    Then these books will feed it!

    Fuse is the sequel to the amazing Pure by Juliana Baggott. The book is due out in February 2013 when my full review will be posted.

    A few words that will be used in my review: dark, compelling, awesome, intriguing.

    * the titles not the story

    CILIP Carnegie & Kate Greenaway Awards long-lists

    Now THESE are long-lists – 68 titles for the Carnegie Award and 64 for the Kate Greenaway Award. As my colleague and friend CazApr1 said on her blog I too am a bit put out by the lack of Heart-Shaped Bruise by Tanya Byrne. HSB was excluded because it had first been published as an adult novel rather than a simultaneous adult/YA publication. There are some excellent titles on the list, I even know some of the authors – but will try not to play favourites. I will have a look at who I think will make it onto the short-list at a later date.

    Books are nominated by librarians that are members of CILIP (The Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals), the nominated books are then checked for eligibility before being placed on the long-list. You can view the criteria for the Carnegie & Kate Greenaway Awards here: Carnegie Award Criteria and the Kate Greenaway Award Criteria.

    I am going to start my Shadowing of the Awards now to flex my reading and reviewing muscles in preparation for becoming a judge in 2014 when there will probably be over 100 titles on each list.

    The CILIP Carnegie Medal longlist:

    Goldilocks on CCTV by John Agard (Frances Lincoln Children’s Books)
    The True Tale of the Monster Billy Dean by David Almond (Puffin Books)
    Soldier Dog by Sam Angus (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    The No. 1 Car Spotter and the Firebird by Atinuke (Walker Books)
    The Traitors by Tom Becker (Scholastic)
    The Terrible Thing That Happened to Barnaby Brocket by John Boyne (Doubleday Children’s Books)
    Jasmine Skies by Sita Brahmachari (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    Spy For The Queen of Scots by Theresa Breslin (Doubleday Children’s Books)
    Naked by Kevin Brooks (Puffin Books)
    Kill All Enemies by Melvin Burgess (Puffin Books)
    Dead Time by Anne Cassidy (Bloomsbury)
    VIII by H.M. Castor (Templar Publishing)
    Dying To Know You by Aidan Chambers (Bodley Head)
    The Broken Road by B.R. Collins (Bloomsbury)
    The Unforgotten Coat by Frank Cottrell Boyce (Walker Books)
    15 Days Without a Head by Dave Cousins (Oxford University Press)
    After the Snow by S.D. Crockett (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    The Weight of Water by Sarah Crossan (Bloomsbury)
    Scramasax by Kevin Crossley-Holland (Quercus Publishing)
    Mortal Chaos by Matt Dickinson (Oxford University Press)
    Sektion 20 by Paul Dowswell (Bloomsbury)
    A Greyhound of a Girl by Roddy Doyle (Marion Lloyd Books)
    Saving Daisy by Phil Earle (Puffin Books)
    Buzzing! by Anneliese Emmans Dean (Brambleby Books)
    The Things We Did For Love by Natasha Farrant (Faber and Faber)
    Trouble in Toadpool by Anne Fine (Doubleday Children’s Books)
    Call Down Thunder by Daniel Finn (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    Far Rockaway by Charlie Fletcher (Hodder Children’s Books)
    The Double Shadow by Sally Gardner (Indigo)
    Maggot Moon by Sally Gardner (Hot Key Books)
    After by Morris Gleitzman (Puffin Books)
    To Be A Cat by Matt Haig (Bodley Head)
    A Face Like Glass by Frances Hardinge (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    Unrest by Michelle Harrison (Simon & Schuster Children’s Books)
    Seraphina by Rachel Hartman (Doubleday Children’s Books)
    The Seeing by Diana Hendry (Bodley Head)
    Daylight Saving by Edward Hogan (Walker Books)
    Hero on a Bicycle by Shirley Hughes (Walker Books)
    The Abominables by Eva Ibbotson (Marion Lloyd Books)
    The Girl in the Mask by Marie-Louise Jensen (Oxford University Press)
    The Prince Who Walked With Lions by Elizabeth Laird (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    In Darkness by Nick Lake (Bloomsbury)
    The Brides of Rollrock Island by Margo Lanagan (David Fickling Books)
    Skulduggery Pleasant: Death Bringer by Derek Landy (HarperCollins Children’s Books)
    Itch by Simon Mayo    (Corgi Children’s Books)
    At Yellow Lake by Jane McLoughlin (Frances Lincoln Children’s Books)
    The Apothecary by Maile Meloy (Andersen Press)
    The Treasure House by Linda Newbery (Orion Children’s Books)
    All Fall Down by Sally Nicholls (Marion Lloyd Books)
    This Dark Endeavour by Kenneth Oppel (Random House David Fickling Books)
    Hitler’s Angel by William Osborne (Chicken House)
    Wonder by R.J. Palacio (Bodley Head)
    Gods and Warriors by Michelle Paver (Puffin Books)
    Burn Mark by Laura Powell (Bloomsbury)
    Black Arts: The Books of Pandemonium by Andrew Prentice and Jonathan Weil (David Fickling Books)
    Mister Creecher by Chris Priestley (Bloomsbury)
    This is Not Forgiveness by Celia Rees (Bloomsbury)
    Goblins by Philip Reeve (Marion Lloyd Books)
    Black Heart Blue by Louisa Reid (Puffin Books)
    Pendragon Legacy: Sword of Light by Katherine Roberts (Templar Publishing)
    Midwinterblood by Marcus Sedgwick (Indigo)
    A Boy and a Bear in a Boat by Dave Shelton (David Fickling Books)
    The Sleeping Army by Francesca Simon (Profile Books)
    The Flask by Nicky Singer (HarperCollins Children’s Books)
    The Scorpio Races by Maggie Stiefvater (Scholastic)
    A Skull in Shadows Lane by Robert Swindells (Corgi Children’s Books)
    A Waste of Good Paper by Sean Taylor (Frances Lincoln Children’s Books)
    Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wein (Electric Monkey)

    The CILIP Kate Greenaway Longlist:

    The Big Snuggle-Up by Nicola Bayley (illustrator) and Brian Patten (Andersen Press)
    North: The Greatest Animal Journey on Earth by Patrick Benson (illustrator) and Nick Dowson (Walker Books)
    How Do You Feel? by Anthony Browne (Walker Books)
    The Artist Who Painted a Blue Horse by Eric Carle (Puffin Books)
    Have You Ever Ever Ever? by Emma Chichester Clark (illustrator) and Colin McNaughton (Walker Books)
    The Pied Piper of Hamelin by Emma Chichester Clark (illustrator) and Michael Morpurgo (Walker Books)
    Lunchtime by Rebecca Cobb (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    The Goggle-Eyed Goats by Christopher Corr (illustrator) and Stephen Davies (Andersen Press)
    Croc and Bird by Alexis Deacon (Hutchinson)
    Soonchild by Alexis Deacon (illustrator) and Russell Hoban (Walker Books)
    The Pirates Next Door by Jonny Duddle (Templar Publishing)
    Arthur’s Dream Boat by Polly Dunbar (Walker Books)
    Rabbityness by Jo Empson (Child’s Play International)
    Friends by Michael Foreman (Andersen Press)
    Wild Child by Lorna Freytag (illustrator) and Jeanne Willis (Walker Books)
    Azzi in Between by Sarah Garland (Frances Lincoln Children’s Books)
    Robin Hood by Anne Yvonne Gilbert (illustrator) and Nicky Raven (Templar Publishing)
    A Bus Called Heaven by Bob Graham (Walker Books)
    Again! by Emily Gravett (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    Matilda’s Cat by Emily Gravett (Macmillan Children’s Books)
    Toys in Space by Mini Grey (Jonathan Cape)
    Oh No, George! by Chris Haughton (Walker Books)
    A First Book of Nature by Mark Hearld (illustrator) and Nicola Davies (Walker Books)
    The Great Snortle Hunt by Kate Hindley (illustrator) and Claire Freedman (Simon & Schuster)
    Goldilocks and Just the One Bear by Leigh Hodgkinson (Nosy Crow)
    Children’s Books)
    Jonathan & Martha by Petr Horáček (Phaidon)
    The Hueys in The New Jumper by Oliver Jeffers (HarperCollins Children’s Books)
    Stuck by Oliver Jeffers (HarperCollins Children’s Books)
    This Moose Belongs to Me by Oliver Jeffers (HarperCollins Children’s Books)
    The Fantastic Flying Books of Mr. Morris Lessmore by W.E. Joyce (co-illustrator and writer) and Joe Bluhm (illustrator) (Simon & Schuster Children’s Books)
    Goldilocks on CCTV by Satoshi Kitamura (illustrator) and John Agard (Frances Lincoln Children’s Books)
    I Want my Hat Back by Jon Klassen (Walker Books)
    An Illustrated Treasury of Scottish Folk and Fairy Tales by Kate Leiper (illustrator) and Theresa Breslin (Floris Books)
    Demolition by Brian Lovelock (illustrator) and Sally Sutton (Walker Books)
    The Skeleton Pirate by David Lucas (Walker Books)
    The Frank Show by David Mackintosh (HarperCollins Children’s Books)
    The Cat and the Fiddle: A Treasury of Nursery Rhymes by Jackie Morris (Frances Lincoln Children’s Books)
    Pirates ‘n’ Pistols by Chris Mould (Hodder Children’s Books)
    The Worst Princess by Sara Ogilvie (illustrator) and Anna Kemp (Simon & Schuster Children’s Books)
    King Jack and the Dragon by Helen Oxenbury (illustrator) and Peter Bently (Puffin Books)
    My Big Shouting Day by Rebecca Patterson (Jonathan Cape)
    Black Dog by Levi Pinfold (Templar Publishing)
    Where is Fred? by Ali Pye (illustrator) and Edward Hardy (Egmont Books)
    The Twelve Days of Christmas by Jane Ray (Orchard Books)
    The Yoga Ogre by Simon Rickerty (illustrator) and Peter Bently (Simon & Schuster Children’s Books)
    One Cool Cat by David Roberts (illustrator) and Susannah Corbett (Egmont Children’s Books)
    Who Am I? by Tony Ross (illustrator) and Gervase Phinn (Andersen Press)
    Fly, Chick, Fly! by Tony Ross (illustrator) and Jeanne Willis (Andersen Press)
    Just Ducks! by Salvatore Rubbino (illustrator) and Nicola Davies (Walker Books)
    Just Imagine by Nick Sharratt (illustrator) and Pippa Goodhart (Doubleday Children’s Books)
    A Boy and a Bear in a Boat by Dave Shelton (David Fickling Books)
    ABC London by Kate Slater (illustrator) and James Dunn (Frances Lincoln Children’s Books)
    Claude at the Circus by Alex T. Smith (Hodder Children’s Books)
    Ella by Alex T. Smith (Scholastic)
    Red Car, Red Bus by Susan Steggall (Frances Lincoln Children’s Books)
    How to Hide a Lion by Helen Stephens (Alison Green Books)
    Jack and the Baked Beanstalk by Colin Stimpson (Templar Publishing)
    Naughty Kitty by Adam Stower (Templar Publishing)
    The Town Mouse and The Country Mouse by Helen Ward (Templar Publishing)
    Leave Me Alone by Lee Wildish (illustrator) and Kes Gray (Hodder Children’s Books)
    The Duckling Gets a Cookie!? by Mo Willems (Walker Books)
    Eric! by Christopher Wormell (Jonathan Cape)
    Dog Loves Drawing by Louise Yates (Jonathan Cape)
    Hans and Matilda by Yokococo (Templar Publishing)

    Hereville: How Mirka Met a Meteorite by Barry Deutsch

    Boldly Going Where No 11-Year-Old Orthodox Jewish Girl has Gone Before

    How Mirka Met a Meteorite is the second book in the Hereville series. The first being Hereville: How Mirka Got Her Sword (Yet Another Troll-Fighting 11-Year-Old Orthodox Jewish Girl).

    Mirka Hirshberg is a spunky, strong-willed eleven-year-old who isn’t interested in knitting lessons from her stepmother, or how-to-find-a-husband advice from her sister, or you-better-not warnings from her brother. There’s only one thing Mirka does want: to fight dragons! But she’ll need a sword – and therein lies the tale!
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    Mirka is back, and this time she takes on a misguided meteor that’s been set in motion by the troll and turned into Mirka’s twin by the witch. Doppelganger Mirka is out to best the real girl. Our heroine will have to beat her other self in a three-part-challenge – or be banished from Hereville!
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    My all-time favourite indie comic is the amazing Bone by Jeff Smith – I can honestly say that I never thought I could find another comic to challenge it in my affections; the early Cerebus books by Dave Sim came close but ultimately fell by the wayside as Dave Sim became progressively weirder.

    Now there is a new challenger on the block – Barry Deutsh’s stories of Mirka and Hereville. If you had not guessed by the tag lines – Mirka is Jewish, Hereville is a shtetl and an undercurrent of Orthodox Jewish life fills the book, Mirka’s family life centres on Shabbos (Shabbat), the Shabbos rituals and family jobs are laid out beautifully in How Mirka got Her Sword and the disruptive effect having a twin has is shown during Shabbos in How Mirka met a Meteorite. Mirka’s family life and relationships are shown to good effect in the Shabbos pages in both books. The love that Barry obviously has for this comes through in the art and the words he uses.

    I am a goy but I have been picking up and using Yiddish words and learning about Jewish culture (and food) for years. I enjoyed immersing myself in a culture that is not my own and even picked up some more words. You do not need to be Jewish or have an understanding of Jewish culture to read or enjoy this book (but it does help).

    Mirka is awesome! I do not think there are many comic books that have 11-year-old heroines; let alone snarky siblings as side-kicks. There are trolls, a witch with a pig, extra-terrestrial beings, bullies, family – no orphans in this story, there is a stepmother she is not of the evil variety, more long-suffering and understanding of Mirka than Mirka can actually see. I love that Mirka argues with absolutely everybody but the only one that seems to get the better of her is her stepmother, she is also teeh one that gives Mirka the mental tools to get out of the scrapes that she finds herself in. The scenes where Mirka talks to her stepmother about her mother are some of the most touching I have seen in a comic.

    Hereville is hilarious, touching, exciting and the best magically real comic I have ever read!

    The Diviners by Libba Bray

    Looking for a book to while away the long nights of Hallowe’en and the days of the Dead?

    May I present to you The Diviners by Libba Bray.

    The Diviners is the sort of book that looks daunting when you pick it up, weighing in at 583 pages in length it is no lightweight.

    It gave me pause for a few seconds. I used those seconds to gaze in adoration at the cover, I may have stroked it in awe. It is a thing of beauty to behold! Silver raised text on a hard cover of dark and blues with a flapper girl in silhouette against a modern skyline and hovering above it all is the all-seeing eye.

    Then I opened the cover and started reading.

    Not having been born in the early years of the 20th century I have no idea what it was like to live through the ’20’s but Libba’s prose swept me away. From the first chapter I was caught up in the final party of the season where young men and women were shaken from their lethargy and boredom by the hostess who produced a ouija board to commune with the other side. I was chilled by the the thread of darkness and unease that wormed its way in that even the bright lights of the mightiest city ever built could not dispel.

     
    New York in 1926 is in the grip of the 18th Amendment to the Constitution better known as Prohibition.It is a time of secret gin parties, flappers and good times that will never end. The Great War is becoming a distant memory, with old anguishes and losses dimmed by time the future has never looked brighter.

    Into New York comes Evie O’Neill, flapper, party girl and labelled as that wicked O’Neill girl by the residents of the town of Zenith.

    She has been exiled from her boring old hometown and shipped off to the bustling streets of New York city – and she is pos-i-tute-ly ecstatic. It’s 1926 and New York is fileld with speakeasies, Ziegfeld girls and rakish pickpockets. the only catch is that she has to live with her uncle Will – and his unhealthy obsession with the occult.

    If you read only one book this Hallowe’en make sure it is The Diviners by Libba Bray!

    The first in a tetralogy, The Diviners will make you ache for the New York of yore while still giving you chills.

    Is a Picture Worth a Thousand Words?

    Cutting a novel to make way for graphic illustrations is hard work, but ultimately very rewarding, says Zella Compton author of The Ten Rules of Skimming.

    When I wrote The Ten Rules of Skimming I had no idea that it would turn out to be half book, half graphic novel. Why would I? I wrote it for young adults, and it’s not often that you see books with multiple illustrations in that genre (although many of the covers are truly awesome).

    But my publisher gave me a choice. He would either print it as a straight novel, or with sequential illustrations on pretty much every page, it was up to me. It took me a few days to decide. The first draft was around 70,000 words, and the publisher told me if I went to an illustrated format I’d have to chop at least 30,000 of them. That was daunting.

    But then I saw some pitch artwork from one of the potential artists, Jess Swainson. She’d drawn two scenes from the book– and they blew my mind. The scenes she’d chosen were so cool. The first was when Adam, the protagonist, is being questioned about how he found his sister’s – and other girls – bodies. The second depicted some of the side-effects of skimming through people’s minds . . . and I loved both drawings. It was like seeing a movie trailer for your favourite book and knowing that the film will do it justice. The excitement swelled in my belly, I couldn’t believe she’d got my characters so spot on. The decision was made.

    Jess and I met for lunch, and I looked over her character roughs. She asked me lots of detailed questions which I’d never thought about. It was really simple stuff like what kind of clothes does Adam wear, and does Jenny-Ray (the female lead) tie her hair back? It made me realise that I am quite sparse in my descriptions, my default position is to leave readers to fill in the blanks. I had to think long and hard about it; thankfully Jess gave jenny-Ray much better dress sense that I ever had.

    The next task was to get rid of the 30,000 extra words (I had used three adjectives where one would do, so that wasn’t too hard) and start planning out the images. My publisher wanted me to aim for one on every page, which meant cutting more and more text. For example, where I would have used a couple of pages to describe the horror of being chased through minds, Jess drew it in half the space.

    I had to be very careful about the images I chose to use. The book is gritty. Physical violence between adults and children, bodies in conservatories and murder. It was a balancing act to work out what is best left to a reader’s imagination (younger siblings do pick up books!), and what to literally show.

    When these broad decisions were taken, I had to think about speech bubbles. Condensing dialogue into three or four words was the hardest part of the process. I have so much respect for comic book creators now!

    As the editing process moved on, the publisher sent Jess final versions of chapters, with broad instructions for what the images should be and the speech bubbles. I ‘signed off’ roughs before she drew the finals. Jess is a genius drawer; it’s fair to say that my favourite part of being an author (so far) was watching the pictures come in and seeing my story from someone else’s eyes.

    Jess drew over 130 images; so based on the old adage that a picture’s worth 1,000 words, I would have had to cut nearly double the length of the first draft. In The Ten Rules of Skimming each picture is actually worth about 300 words, and I am delighted with the end result: a taut thriller which leaps off the page.

    The Ten Rules of Skimming by Zella Compton and Jess Swainson is available to order from all good bookshops, from Mogzilla.co.uk (free postage), from Amazon, Sainsburys (online) and WH Smith (online).

    For more information visit: www.zellacompton.co.uk.

    Maggot Moon by Sally Gardner


    What if the football hadn’t gone over the wall? What if Hector had never gone looking for it? What if he hadn’t kept the dark secrets to himself? What if…

    Then I suppose I would be telling myself another story. You see, the ‘what if’s’ are as boundless as the stars.

    I am not a person prone to jealous fits, I like to think of myself as living on a fairly even keel but Sally Gardner made me jealous!

    Not because she is a fantastic author and a lovely person (she is!) but because she has taken a complex concept (alternate earth, a moon landing conpsiracy theory and a Britain without anything that made it great – except the courage and determination of a boy who missed his friend) and then told the story using simple, accessible language and made a beautiful, haunting story!

    Maggot Moon is perfect! I have never said that about a book before – and it is possible that I may never say it again.

    If, before I had read it, someone had said to me, “Hey you know that book by Sally Gardner the one with the kid with two different coloured eyes looking out from the cover and a ladder stretching from his head to a moon writhing with maggots, um… Maggot Moon – well that book is perfect!”

    I probably would not have believed them. I would have picked up the book and read it much like I hope that you do once you have finished reading this review – find a copy and read it! It might make you smile, it may make you cry but it will make you think!

    Narrated in an alternate Britain against the desperate race to the moon, Maggot Moon is a complex story, simply told, by Standish Treadwell (Can’t read, can’t write. Standish Treadwell isn’t bright.) a boy with a dyslexia, in a Britain where the disabled are locked away with dissidents and other non-people that have earned the displeasure of the state.

    With his best friend missing, a moon man in his basement and a potential opportunity to escape, Standish must make a choice and possibly find out the truth about what is happening on the other side of the wall.

    Exciting
    Thought-provoking
    Heartbreaking

    Perfect!

    The Importance of the CILIP Carnegie & Kate Greenaway Children's Book Award

    On Wednesday the CILIP Youth Libraries Group London held our annual CKG Awards Nominations Party, on Thursday I posted a short write up of the evening and posted the link to twitter. I was soon embroiled in a discussion about the merits of Children’s and Young Adult Book Awards where selections are made by adults (in the CKG case by Librarians) versus Awards where children and young people responsible for the selection of the long and short lists as well as choosing the winner.

    It is not the first time that I have had an encounter with friends and colleagues who believe that awards for children’s literature should be selected by children themselves. Indeed there are a growing number of regional and national awards that have children either as the selectors and judges or both. These include the Red House Children’s Book Award, The Blue Peter Book Awards, the Leeds Book Awards and The Berkshire Book Award amongst others.

    Is it really so awful for one award to have the same literary rigour as something for adult books, for example the Man Booker, if only to highlight the literary merit of children’s books to those that decry writing for children as ‘easy’?

    Some of the accusations that I have heard levelled against the CKG Awards range from the belief that the awards focus on books that adults think children should read to statements like “I think that the wrong book won so your award is flawed!”. As the eligibility for nomination is simply that a book has to have been published for children and young people in the UK in that year, and not previously in another country, the long list can include all sorts of things. The judging criteria avoid subjective bias and to make sure the books are looked at objectively. This can and sometimes has led to less populist books winning the award – much to the consternation of onlookers who, through no fault of their own, are unaware of the selection and judging process. Saying that the shortlist is of books that children don’t like is, quite frankly, an offence to the children that do enjoy these books whether or not they are a mainstream success.

    My good friend and colleague Caroline tweeted something that I totally agree with (and wish I had said): ”Children’s/School Librarians know what kids like/can access. Not only ‘worthy’ books are long listed”

    On the CKG website in the frequently asked questions section, the concerns raised by the awards detractors are answered

    What is unique about the Carnegie Medal and the Kate Greenaway Medal?

    The Carnegie Medal and the Kate Greenaway Medal are unique in that they are awarded by librarians who work closely with books and children. The books that are nominated for the awards are nominated by library professionals and not by publishers, a democratic process which ensures that any title has an equal chance of being considered for the Awards. The judges are totally independent and make their choices purely on their own judgement of the titles’ merits against the criteria. Throughout their history the Carnegie and Kate Greenaway Medals have provided a literary standard by which other books are measured and they are the Medals most authors and illustrators want to win.

    Are young people’s opinions taken into account when the winners are chosen?

    It is important to recognise that the Medals are awarded by librarians to writers and artists that they wish to honour for the outstanding books they have created. Naturally the judges do consider children’s and young people’s responses to the books as a part of their assessment, but the criteria take into account a broad range of other factors, such as construction of the plot, the strength of the characterisation and the quality of the writer’s style. Outstanding literary or artistic quality are the most important elements when choosing the winner of these awards; there are several other awards where popularity with children and young people is the main criterion.

    The emphasis placed on the above sentences is is mine.

    The target audiences are involved in the Awards via the Shadowing scheme, whereby groups of young people are encouraged to read the books and debate with other group members, as well as interacting with other groups through the shadowing website. Opening a dialogue on how the winners are selected is an important part of these groups, as is the debate once the winners have been announced, as feelings can run high especially when some of the group believes the ‘wrong’ book wins.

    Taking the CKG Awards to task because young people are not involved in the selection or judging process is just as wrong as stating that other children’s book awards are less valid because the choices are made subjectively. The variety and abundance of awards is a good thing, surely there’s no such thing as too much publicity for reading!

    To find out more about the CILIP Carnegie and Kate Greenaway Medals, including the judging criteria, have a look at the website www.carnegiegreenaway.org.uk
    ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    This post was co-authored by @mattlibrarian and @CazApr1 both of whom will be Shadowing the Carnegie & Kate Greenaway Awards this year.