… that 94.7 percent of kids’ books are crud.
Mac being Mac Barnett, the current National Ambassador for Young People’s Literature and best-selling author for young readers.
In his new book Make Believe: on Telling Stories to Children he has written “I have a nagging fear that children’s literature suffers from a slightly higher crud percentage than literature as a whole…maybe more like 94.7 percent of kids’ books are crud.“
A hyperbolic statement? Almost certainly, but also utterly tone deaf and incredibly dismissive of the tens of thousands of authors across the world who write books for children and young readers. Who gets to chose which books are worthy and which ones are, not to put too fine a point on it… crud?
Mac is not alone in believing that this, there are people and organizations around, like Moms for Liberty and their fellow travelers, who believe that many kids books are crud, full of themes, ideas and people that they do not want their children exposed to. Mac’s belief gives cover and credence to these people and their hateful views.
Who knows, Mac’s book may be a paean to children’s literature, extolling its virtues, but sadly the nagging fear that he shares may be all that many people take away from it. This negative publicity may in fact deter people who may benefit from reading it from picking it up. I have ordered a copy and will read (and review) it as I have long been a fan of his work, but honestly he (or his editor) should have thought about that sentence before the book was published.
If this is something he truly believes then he should resign the position of ambassador and let someone who truly sees the value young people’s literature assume the position!
