The Fifth Circuit Federal Appeals Court ruled en banc that the First Amendment cannot be used to challenge book removals in Public Libraries as a library’s collection decisions are government speech and
therefore not subject to Free Speech challenge.
ACLU Attorney Josh Block has a comprehensive thread on Bluesky that covers this breaking news:
You can read their ruling here:
The ruling is summarized as: Plaintiffs have a First Amendment right to read books. They don’t
have a First Amendment right to force a public library to provide them. So I
agree that we should reverse, and accordingly concur.
The ruling was not unanimous as three judges dissented, the dissent is also included above and is worth reading in full. The dissent begins with: Because the majority forsakes core First Amendment principles and
controlling Supreme Court law, I dissent.
and ends with: Because I would not have our court “join the book burners,” I dissent.
The Fifth Circuit Court is widely considered to be the most conservative court in the US. It remains to be seen if this ruling will be overturned on appeal, but it is concerning that the activist judges on the court are trying to remove the First Amendment from the arsenal of people fighting to prevent book bans ad censorship in libraries.
You can find out more about the court case Little vs Llano county here: https://www.aclu.org/cases/little-v-llano-county
Links to More Information
5th Circuit rules Texas library patrons have no First Amendment right to information – Austin-American Statesman